About Us


Our mission is to provide comprehensive property and casualty insurance products of the highest quality and to conduct our business by biblical principles of love, justice and integrity. We are committed to maintaining lasting relationships with policyholders, independent agents and employees; giving excellent customer service; promoting safety and loss prevention; and contributing a portion of our operating profits to charitable organizations.

Goodville Mutual works exclusively through independent insurance agents. If you want information about Goodville products, services, or rates please contact an agent near you. Click here to find an agent.


Popular, reliable products

  • Competitive products for homes, autos, farms, businesses and churches


  • Affordable coverage options
  • Rewarding discounts available
  • Innovative online service technology


  • A VIII (Excellent) rating by A. M. Best Company
  • Merged strengths with six companies since 1996
  • Strong new client growth, exceptional loyalty
  • Solid reinsurance treaties for response in disaster


  • Represented by local independent agents you know and trust
  • Founded in 1926 by Mennonite business leaders in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania
  • Contributions support community, church, educational and disaster relief programs

Personal, fast and fair

  • Friendly and courteous service
  • Transactions processed promptly, fairly and accurately
  • Personal attention given to each individual
  • 24/7 claim services and payment options


  • Your suggestions encouraged and respected
  • Morally and ethically acceptable investments selected
  • Business decisions guided by biblical principles